Top 10 Must-Try American Candies for Every Sweet Tooth

Ever wonder why candy holds such a special place in our hearts? Here’s something to chew on: the average American consumes about 22 pounds of candy annually. That’s a sugar-packed joyride, enough to keep any sweet tooth satisfied.

If you’re curious about which treats deserve a spot in your candy stash, keep reading. This guide will introduce you to some of the most iconic and flavorful confections you need to try.

Key Points:

  • Discover colorful, crunchy, and chewy options for all preferences.
  • Learn what makes specific candies timeless favorites.
  • Explore unique treats that stand out from the pack.

1. Nerds ─ Colorful Crunchy Treats for Fans of Sweet and Sour

Nerds are an all-time classic for those who enjoy a fun, crunchy, and tangy treat. These tiny, pebble-like candies pack a punch of flavor in every handful. Each box is a two-flavor combo, with options like grape and strawberry or watermelon and cherry.

What makes them special is their vibrant, crunchy texture paired with their sweet and sour balance. They’re the perfect candy to snack on while watching a movie or just for a midday pick-me-up. You can find your favorite Nerds at OhMyCandyBox and add a little color to your day.

2. Reese’s ─ A Perfect Match of Peanut Butter and Chocolate

Reese’s Cups are more than candy—they’re an experience. The creamy peanut butter inside a smooth chocolate shell feels like the edible version of a warm hug. Whether you go for the original cups, the bite-sized Reese’s Pieces, or the seasonal shapes (hello, pumpkin and egg lovers), each option delivers the same sweet and salty magic.

Did You Know?

Reese’s were invented in the 1920s, but they didn’t gain widespread popularity until Hershey’s began distributing them in the 1960s. Today, they’re one of the best-selling candies in the U.S.

Why Reese’s Deserves a Spot in Your Candy Bowl:

  1. Salty and sweet flavors in perfect harmony.
  2. Variety of options for every occasion.
  3. Loved by candy enthusiasts for over 100 years.

3. Starburst ─ Tiny Squares of Fruity Flavor

Starburst squares are a fruit lover’s dream. Each chewy candy is bursting with intense flavors, making every bite feel like a little celebration. The original pack includes four iconic flavors: strawberry, cherry, orange, and lemon. But if you’re feeling adventurous, tropical and sour packs bring exciting twists to the mix.

Starburst candies are also versatile. Use them as a colorful cake topper, melt them into candy crafts, or enjoy them straight from the pack. No matter how you eat them, they never disappoint.

Source: flickr.com

4. M&Ms ─ Chocolate Buttons with Big Personality

There’s no candy quite like M&Ms. The crispy candy shell encasing smooth milk chocolate has made them a favorite for decades. Whether you prefer peanut, pretzel, or caramel-filled varieties, M&Ms deliver joy in every bite. Plus, their colorful coating makes them as visually appealing as they are tasty.

Want to add some fun to your snacks? Mix M&Ms with popcorn for a sweet and salty movie treat. Or, use them in baking to create colorful cookies and cakes.

5. The Sweet and Sour Charm of Sour Patch Kids

Sour Patch Kids are little tricksters. They start with an intense sourness before mellowing into a pleasant sweetness. Their gummy texture makes them fun to eat, and they come in a variety of flavors, from the original mix to watermelon and blue raspberry.

Fun fact ─ Sour Patch Kids were initially called Mars Men when they launched in the 1970s, capitalizing on the space craze of that era. They were rebranded in the 1980s to appeal to kids who loved sour candies.

For an even better experience, freeze them for a chewy and refreshing treat.

6. Hershey’s ─ The Iconic Chocolate Bar

Source: nytimes.com

Hershey’s chocolate bars are timeless. Whether you prefer plain milk chocolate or variations like cookies ‘n’ cream or almond-filled, Hershey’s has something for everyone. These bars are the foundation of countless s’mores and baking recipes, but they’re just as satisfying when enjoyed on their own.

The Hershey Company has been making chocolate for over a century, earning its spot as one of the most recognizable brands in the world. It’s simple, reliable, and always satisfying.

7. Skittles ─ A Fruity Rainbow Explosion

Skittles are a playful candy with bold flavors. Every pack offers a mix of sweet and tangy options, including fan favorites like strawberry, lime, and grape. Their tagline, “Taste the Rainbow,” fits perfectly because each bite brings a burst of fruity fun.

Want to take Skittles to the next level? Use them as toppings for desserts or freeze them for a crunchy twist. Skittles are also great for color-coded candy crafts if you’re feeling creative.

8. Tootsie Rolls – A Chocolatey Chew

Tootsie Rolls may look simple, but they’ve been a beloved candy for generations. Their chewy texture and mild chocolate flavor set them apart from other candies. Plus, they’re long-lasting, making them a perfect choice for a candy fix that won’t disappear too quickly.

Key benefit ─ Tootsie Rolls are versatile—they’re great for snacking, decorating desserts, or even as fillers for candy-themed gift bags.

9. PayDay – A Peanut Lover’s Dream

Source: candyfunhouse.ca

PayDay bars skip the chocolate and go straight for salty, nutty satisfaction. Made of a caramel core rolled in salted peanuts, they’re a unique candy that balances sweet and savory perfectly. If you’re a fan of peanuts, PayDay bars are a must-try.

10. AirHeads – A Stretch of Sweetness

AirHeads delivers stretchy, chewy candy fun in a range of fruity flavors. The intense taste of watermelon, blue raspberry, and cherry has made them a favorite among kids and adults alike. Their unique texture and bright colors make them stand out in the candy aisle.

Recommendation ─ Use AirHeads for candy crafts or create your own sour strip by sprinkling them with citric acid.

How to Pick Your Favorite Treat

With so many options, choosing a candy might feel like a daunting task. Think about what you enjoy most—do you prefer fruity or chocolatey? Crunchy or chewy? Sour or sweet? Let your cravings guide you.

Final Tip: Keep a mix of candies on hand to suit different moods. Whether you’re snacking solo or sharing with friends, a well-stocked candy stash is always a good idea.